Lindsey is a freshman at Holy Cross, playing both soccer and basketball for the Saints. At Elkhart Christian Academy she was a three sport athlete in soccer, basketball, and softball. Her awards for soccer included the team defensive award, offensive award, eagle award, and she was all named to first team All-Conference her junior and senior year. In basketball she received the team hustle award, offensive award, defensive award, and was named first team All-Conference during her junior and senior years. While playing softball she acquired the team offensive award her junior and senior year, and was named first team All-Conference junior and senior year.